The primary buds on this Chardonnay vine were all killed, but secondary and tertiary buds stepped in to provide a partial crop. At some locations, the vine was killed to the snow line and a cordon will need to be developed. (Richard Lehnert/Good Fruit Grower)
Across Michigan, vinifera grapes were hammered by last winter’s cold conditions, said Mark Longstroth, Michigan State University’s tree fruit educator in Van Buren County in southwest Michigan.
That statement was true across the Midwest and Northeast as growers and industry observers surveyed the damage after what is considered a “test winter.”
Regrowth this spring was from secondary and tertiary buds, Longstroth said. Primary buds were mostly dead. Most hybrid varieties and juice grapes were hurt if they were overcropped last year.
“In 1994, we had vines collapsing in the summer and had to bring a lot of the vinifera up from the snow line,” Longstroth said. “This year we’re telling growers to wait and see where the vine develops new shoots before doing anything drastic.”
Duke Elsner, the Michigan State University fruit educator who works with wine grapes in northwest Michigan, reported that temperatures there were not quite as cold as further south in Longstroth’s area but did dip to -20˚F one night and -10˚F on several nights.
Elsner sampled grape buds in late March.
“The results revealed good news and bad news, depending on the variety,” he reported. “Riesling showed a solid 84 percent primary bud survival rate with Chardonnay not far behind at 74 percent. Each had over 90 percent of their secondary buds alive and well.
“Pinot Gris and Gewürztraminer did not do as well, with just over 50 percent survival of primary buds. Pinot Noir and Cabernet Franc both came in at under 50 percent live primary buds, but each of these varieties showed decent survival rates for the secondary buds, so it should be possible to adjust pruning practices to achieve a typical crop load for the 2014 season.”
A number of other varieties exhibited much greater bud mortality, he said. Pinot Blanc had only 37 percent and 45 percent survival of primary and secondary buds, respectively. Gruner Veltliner had under 5 percent of the primary and secondary buds alive in his sample.
Eight other promising Vitis vinifera wine varieties being tested at the Northwest Michigan Horticultural Research Center came in at under 30 percent primary bud survival. Muscat was also hard-hit by the cold.
“As would be expected, hybrid varieties fared much better, as cold hardiness is one of the characteristics typically selected for in breeding programs,” Elsner said. “Several hybrid varieties showed greater than 80 percent survival of primary buds.”
In Ohio, viticulturist Imed Dami reported near total losses of primary buds on vinifera varieties such as Riesling, Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, Cabernet Franc, Pinot Gris, and Cabernet Sauvignon.
He pegged losses at 57 percent on hybrids such as Vidal Blanc, Chambourcin, Traminette, and Seyval, and 30 percent on the native varieties Concord, Catawba, and Niagara.
Dami saw extensive damage to secondary and tertiary buds on the vines at grape research stations in Wooster and Kingsville. He estimates that 20 percent of the grapevines in Ohio will be lost.
As in Michigan, the growth of winemaking in Ohio has been fostered by a variety shift that began 40 years ago from native varieties to hybrids and then to vinifera in the 1990s.
Evidence of increasingly mild winters spurred growers to plant tenderer varieties, but last winter’s extreme cold showed that even in a warmer world, the risk of extreme weather hasn’t lessened.
Temperatures hit -14˚F in Ohio last winter—even as far south as southeastern Ohio.
Disaster in New York
In New York’s Finger Lakes region, the U.S. Department of Agriculture declared 19 counties a disaster area. The declaration means the federal agency will provide financial assistance to grape growers to replant or rehabilitate their vines after months of frigid temperatures, with lows ranging from -7˚F to -18˚F.
Cornell University researchers conducted tests suggesting that up to 50 percent of the region’s Riesling, Gewürztraminer, Sauvignon Blanc, Chardonnay, and Cabernet Franc vines revealed bud damage. Some vintners saw 100 percent of their vineyards damaged.
The researchers say that at temperatures below -14˚F, even Riesling, the most cold-resistant of the Vitis vinifera cultivars, would sustain heavy damage. The deep freeze is particularly hard on the vines’ primary buds, which carry most of the coming season’s fruit.
Riesling, the signature grape of the Finger Lakes region, experienced the worst year in a decade due to the subzero temperatures, Hans Walter-Peterson, a grape educator at Cornell University, told the Wall Street Journal. “This year knocks you for a loop,” he said.
The cold winter may give new impetus to plantings of cold-hardy grapes like those developed by the University of Minnesota. Four varieties—Frontenac, Frontenac Gris, La Crescent, and especially Marquette—all products of the University of Minnesota’s grape-breeding program, survive temperatures well below -20˚F.
The wine industry has, however, mostly used these new varieties to expand wine grape growing country beyond traditional areas.
“I never dreamed that I’d be seeing any grapes produced in the Thousand Islands region of New York, where winter temperatures often drop into the -30s,” Tim Martinson, senior Extension viticulture specialist with Cornell University, told the Minnesota Grape Growers Association at their meeting in February.
“The cold-hardy Minnesota and Swenson hybrids made it possible to do so, and we now have a vibrant and growing winery industry both near Watertown and in the Lake Champlain region.”
New growers and wineries have expanded fast in the last two decades. Since the first University of Minnesota grape variety, Frontenac, was released in 1996, producers in 12 states have planted an estimated 5,400 acres of cold-hardy grapes, including 3,260 acres of the University of Minnesota varieties.
The success of breeding for cold climates spurred the Northern Grapes Project, funded by USDA’s Specialty Crop Research Initiative. The idea is to encourage wine production in colder climates.
States in the project are Connecticut, Illinois, Iowa, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New York, North Dakota, South Dakota, Vermont, and Wisconsin.
After growing up on a Michigan dairy farm, Richard Lehnert began writing about farming in 1962, while still a junior studying journalism at Michigan State University. He worked at newspapers for a year before joining the staff of Michigan Farmer, where he spent 26 years, the last 15 as chief editor. He was a member of the staff of Good Fruit Grower from 2010 until 2015.
Read his stories: Story Index